
Is the photo known as "Kaloma" really Wyatt Earp's common-law wife, Josephine Sarah Marcus, also known as Josephine Sara Marcus Earp? No, it's not.
While the "Kaloma" photo was supposedly taken in Tombstone, Arizona, in 1881, by photographer C. S. Fly, who was known for his reproducing pictures, the image is not Josephine Sara Marcus. And no, no matter what you saw in the movie Tombstone (1993), Josephine Sara Marcus did not pose for the photo.
While that might be seen as bad news to Wyatt Earp fans, and fans of the movie Tombstone (1993), it's just a fact that the famous "Kaloma" photograph is not Josephine Sarah Marcus, nor was it taken in Tombstone in 1881 by C. S. Fly.
The photo of "Kaloma" has no connection to C. S. Fly. In fact, photographer Camillus S. Fly marketed and stamped his studio name on his work. No authentic copies of "Kaloma" have ever been found marketed and stamped his studio name, or on C. S. Fly studio mounts. Besides, the photographic style and silver-gelatin printing process belong to the 1910s and not that of the 1880s.
Of course, while the myth connecting it to photographer C. S. Fly has been thoroughly debunked, for folks like me who love the hear about the real story behind such fabrications, I think the true story of the photo and how it became tied to Wyatt Earp is a pretty good story.
Why couldn't it be Josephine Sarah Marcus?
Well, Josephine Sarah Marcus was born in 1861. The "Kaloma" photograph was actually created in 1914. That means that Josephine Sarah Marcus would have been 53 years old when the photo was made. Obviously, the woman in the portrait is clearly in her late teens or early twenties, and not close to looking like a woman in her 50s at the turn of the 20th Century.
By 1914, Josephine Sarah Marcus and Wyatt Earp had been together as common-law partners for over 30 years. She lived with Wyatt Earp for 47 years as a common-law wife and outlived him by nearly 16 years.
How The Myth Started
The "Kaloma" myth started with a book cover in 1976. The false identification began when author Glenn Boyer used an airbrushed version of the "Kaloma" print on the cover of his controversial book, I Married Wyatt Earp (1976). Boyer tried to claim that he acquired the photo in the 1950s, insisting that it was a photo of a young Josephine Sarah Marcus.
In his book, I Married Wyatt Earp (1976), writer Glenn Boyer originally promoted his book as a memoir by Josephine Sarah Marcus. Supposedly, the book was edited by Boyer from her personal papers where she described her common-law marriage to Wyatt Earp. The book was later exposed as a complete fraud fabricated by Boyer.
Frankly, "Earp experts," or at least those people who claim to be Earp experts should have known something was fishy about Boyer's stories about the photo since his stories are said to have changed over time. Boyer's stories about where the photo came from, its origin and even its ownership were all later to be proven to be a hoax.
Boyer's standing shifted dramatically going from hero to zero once people started scrutinizing his source material. In fact, Boyer was only revealed as a fraud when people started questioning his sources instead of just taking Boyer's word that his sources were legit. It was only when people started really noting some major historical controversies in Boyer's work that Boyer's reputation collapsed.
Boyer gained immense credibility in the 1960s and 1970s when he said he befriended Earp descendants and supposedly uncovered "genuine" historical details about the Earps. Boyer was hailed as the the first Earp-researcher to reveal the existence of Wyatt Earp's "second wife" Mattie Blaylock.
Wyatt Earp's only legal marriage was to his first wife, Urilla Sutherland who he married in 1870. She died the same year. His later long-term partners, including Mattie Blaylock and Josephine Marcus, were "common-law" relationships.
Wyatt Earp was not legally married to Celia Ann "Mattie" Blaylock. She was his common-law wife for roughly six years from about 1878 to 1881. They lived together as partners and she was listed as his wife in the 1880 U.S. Census in Tombstone, Arizona, though no official or legal marriage ceremony ever took place. They met around 1876 in Dodge City, Kansas, and traveled together through New Mexico and Arizona, including Tombstone, before Wyatt Earp left her for Josephine Sarah "Sadie" Marcus.
As for Glenn Boyer, it's said that he like the "Icon" nickname. Due to his access to family papers and prolific writing, Boyer was nicknamed "The Icon" and widely viewed as the reigning authority on Earp history. That finally changed in the 1990s when Earp historians, including Casey Tefertiller and Gary L. Roberts, asked to verify the primary documents Boyer cited in his books. Boyer repeatedly refused to provide copies of his source materials.
Investigations eventually revealed that significant portions of Boyer's I Married Wyatt Earp and his other works contained invented dialogue, discrepancies, and fabricated characters. One of the individuals Boyer claimed to have interviewed was exposed as entirely fictional. Boyer defended his work by claiming he was a "literary artist" rather than a strict academic historian.
To his credit, Bob Boze Bell and True West Magazine reassessed Boyer's works on the Earps. In fact, following Boyer's death in 2013, True West Magazine noted in its obituary that while Boyer had indeed been the acknowledged expert on Wyatt Earp for years, his credibility ultimately crumbled when his methods were exposed.
The Photo Of "Kaloma" Achieved Legendary Status
The Photo Of "Kaloma" Achieved Legendary Status
It's true. The photo of "Kaloma" photo gained legendary status after author Glenn Boyer featured an airbrushed version of the photo on the cover of his book, I Married Wyatt Earp. Remember, Boyer tried to pass off his book, published by the University of Arizona Press, as the authentic memoir of Wyatt Earp's common-law wife, Josephine Sarah Marcus. Boyer claimed that the cropped airbrushed version of "Kaloma" on the dust jacket was a portrait of Wyatt Earp's common-law wife, Josephine Sarah Marcus taken in Tombstone in 1881.
Of course, because Boyer used the photo of "Kaloma" on the cover of his book I Married Wyatt Earp, he linked the "Kaloma" image to Wyatt Earp. After that, Hollywood helped to promote the myth that the photo was Wyatt Earp's common-law wife by featuring it in a scene in the 1993 film Tombstone. In the movie, there's a scene where actress Dana Delany portrays Josephine Sarah Marcus, having her photo taken by photographer Camillus S. Fly in his studio in Tombstone, while posing in a sheer gown identical to the "Kaloma" portrait.
Hollywood's effort to include that scene in the movie Tombstone cemented the false connection between Josephine Sarah Marcus and the 1914 pin-up in popular culture. It's true. Hollywood helped to create the misconception that the photo was of Wyatt Earp's common-law wife. And when that happened, it spurred major auction houses in the 1990s to incorrectly list prints of the "Kaloma" photograph as portraits of Josephine Sarah Marcus.
So What's The Real History of the "Kaloma"1914 Commercial Print?
During World War I, from 1914–1918, formal pin-up girls in the modern sense was transitioning out of the late-19th-century "Gibson Girl" ideal. But, that didn't stop soldiers on both sides of the conflict in World War I from carrying and sharing early forms of printed photos and postcards.
The photo which we known today as the "Kaloma" photograph was copyrighted in 1914 by the Pastime Novelty Company of New York, and was a World War I pin-up.
So Who Was She And Where Did The Name "Kaloma" Come From?
Well, that's the rest of the story. First, no one knows who she is. Her identity has been speculated to be a few different New York "artists' models" of that era. And yes, while the woman in the famous 1914 "Kaloma" photograph strongly resembles Evelyn Nesbit, no one can prove with certainty that she is the model.
As for its name "Kaloma"? The photograph was used on the cover for a 1914 sheet music. The sheet music was titled "Kaloma." It was the cover to the sheet music for a "Valse Hesitante," also known as the "Hesitation Waltz," which is a 1914 solo piano piece composed by Giré Goulineaux, a pseudonym for composer Johann C. Schmid. The solo piano music was published in 1914 by the Cosmopolitan Music Publishing Company in New York City.
The sheet music featured a risqué 1914 photograph titled "Kaloma." Copyrighted by M.L. Pressler, the photo shows an unidentified young woman posing in a sheer gauze peignoir. Of course, the photo gained popularity independently of the music sheet cover at the time and later during World War I.
Will we ever know for certain who she is? Probably not. But really, that doesn't matter. What we know for certain is that she's not Wyatt Earp's common-law wife, Josephine Sarah Marcus. And that photograph wasn't taken in Tombstone in 1881, no matter if it was in a movie.
Tom Correa

