Sunday, April 20, 2014

Wyatt Earp's OK Corral Gun Was Not A Colt

Wyatt Earp, 1883
Dear Friends,

I just read where the news is reporting that another gun that Wyatt Earp supposedly used at the OK Corral sold for $225,000 at auction.

Yep, on April 18, 2014, an Associated Press report out of Scottsdale, Arizona, said that a gun "thought to have been" used by Wyatt Earp during the famous OK Corral shootout in Tombstone Arizona back in 1881 has sold for $225,000.

The Colt sold for quite a bit higher than its estimated value. That's right, it sold for more than it was worth -- but then again, people who buy such things usually have more money than they know what to do with.

The report said that a telephone bidder in New Mexico made the winning bid for the Colt Single Action revolver in .45 caliber. J. Levine Auction & Appraisal officials say an auction of numerous items related to Earp and his family in Scottsdale brought in more than $445,000.

The auction house initially valued the Colt between $100,000 and $150,000. The items belonged to the estate of Glenn Boyer, an author of several books on Earp. Boyer died in February 2013. Some have questioned the item's authenticity while others say Boyer was a credible researcher. For me, it just my opinion, but I believe Boyer proved himself a fraud later in life. 

A Chandler, Arizona, man spent $150,000 on a shotgun owned by Earp, a family archive and other items. Back in 2012 the guns used by Bonnie and Clyde were sold at auction for over half a million dollars. And yes, one of Annie Oakley’s guns sold for $143,400 -- which really does seem like a steal compared to Earp’s gun.

While the Colt was the highlight of the auction, Wyatt Earp’s Winchester shotgun and another Colt revolver owned by Wyatt’s brother Virgil were also sold at the auction. The former sold for less than its estimated value of $125,000, selling for only $50,000. But Virgil Earp’s gun sold for $37,500, higher than the estimated value of $30,000.

Unfortunately, there was a little bit of controversy surrounding the Wyatt Earp gun. Some historians claimed that Boyer fabricated portions of his books and the Colt pistol once had the barrel, grip, and cylinder replaced in addition to having its serial number rubbed off.

So why do I say "supposed" gun used at the OK Corral shootout?

It's because he didn't use a Colt pistol at the OK Corral

In The History of Smith & Wesson Firearms by Dean K. Boorman, published by Globe Pequot Press, in 2002, he reported that Wyatt Earp used a Smith & Wesson Model 3 and not a Colt at the gunfight near the OK Corral.

In Age of The Gunfighter by Joseph G. Rosa, published by University of Oklahoma Press, in 1993, he states that Wyatt Earp preferred the Smith & Wesson Model 3 over a Colt at the gunfight near the OK Corral.


Yes, most Old West historians agree that Wyatt Earp did not use a Colt pistol at the gunfight near the OK Corral. In fact, according to Wyatt Earp himself through his biographer Stuart Lake, he was actually armed with a Smith & Wesson Model 3 during that shootout.

In Earp's case, as stated above, he was given the S&W Model 3 American by The Tombstone Epitaph owner and who was also Tombstone's Mayor, John Clum. We know this to be fact.

The U.S. Army adopted the .44 S&W American caliber Smith & Wesson Model 3 revolver in 1870, making the Model 3 revolver the first standard-issue cartridge-firing revolver in US service.

Most military pistols until that point were black powder cap and ball revolvers. The Smith & Wesson Model 3 was a single-action, cartridge-firing, top-break revolver produced by Smith & Wesson from circa 1870 to 1915. It was produced in several variations and sub-variations.
Smith & Wesson New Model 3
In 1877, Smith & Wesson discontinued production of its other Model 3 variation's such as the American, Russian, and Schofield -- in favor a new improved design called the New Model 3 in 1878.

Smith & Wesson New Model 3 was their perfected single action top break revolver, generally smaller and lighter than previous models. Because it was smaller and lighter, it was more concealable.

That model returned to the original Smith & Wesson barrel latch system, a change stemming mainly from the company's desire to stop paying royalties to George W. Schofield. It was the most popular revolver of the later frontier era. In fact, according to records, more Smith & Wesson New Model 3's were made than Colt Single Action Army pistols during the 19th century -- though the majority went to foreign military contracts.

Among Lawmen and Outlaws

The standard barrel length was 6.5". But as the desire for shorter barrels were in demand by lawmen around the country, many Schofields were purchased as surplus by distributors and they had the barrels shortened to 5" and refinished in nickel. Nice concealability and faster to get it into play when needed.


If you're wondering where the Buntline Special myth started, it was Wyatt Earp's book written by Stuart Lake. That's where the whole Buntline Special myth comes from. From what all of the evidence shows. a Smith & Wesson Model 3 revolver was famously used by Wyatt Earp during the OK Corral gunfight.

The Smith & Wesson Model 3 American in .44 S&W that Wyatt Earp owned was given to him by John Clum just days before the OK Corral shootout. Clum was mayor of Tombstone and owner/editor of the Tombstone Epitath. I believe we can only go with what Clum and eyewitnesses said as for what pistol he used at the OK Corral. 

The idea that Earp carried a Buntline Special given to him by Ned Buntline is all fictional. That was something that Wyatt Earp supposedly told Stuart Lake for Earp's biography. I don't believe the Buntline Special ever existed. And if it did, I'd love to know how Ned Buntline was able to present those long barreled Colt commemorative pistols to a few lawmen who were not yet even lawmen at the time the Ned Buntline was alive? Great trick, but it can't be done.  

The reason that people accept the idea that Wyatt Earp carried the Buntline Special at the OK Corral was because of Earp's book which has been disproved as work of fiction, and of course Hollywood.

And by the way, historian Lee Silva did not believe that Waytt Earp would carry a Smith & Wesson Model 3 American to the shootout near the OK Corral. Among the things that Silva is reported to have said is, "By 1881 the [Smith & Wesson] American Model and its ammunition were obsolete, and it is doubtful Wyatt Earp would have trusted his life to such a gun." 

Of course Wyatt Earp had a smaller caliber Smith & Wesson taken off of him in Alaska and it today sits behind the bar at the Red Dog Saloon there in Alaska. So frankly, he must have trusted his life to it even though it was a smaller caliber.

But more so, as for Silva believing that the S&W Model 3 American was obsolete because of the round it used, Theodore Roosevelt for one did not feel that way at all. In fact Teddy Roosevelt specifically ordered a Smith & Wesson Model 3 American as his sidearm of choice to accompany him to Cuba during the Spanish-American War in 1898. 

And while Silva felt that Wyatt Earp would never have armed himself with such a weapon, the list of lawmen and outlaws who used it and not Colts is very long indeed. For example, the Smith & Wesson Model 3 was popular with lawmen and outlaws in the Old West. Among those who favored the Smith & Wesson Model 3 and its faster reloading capability were, outlaws John Wesley Hardin, Billy the Kid, Frank and Jesse James, showman Buffalo Bill Cody, trick shooter Annie Oakley, and lawmen Virgil and Wyatt Earp, Dallas Stoudenmire, and Pat Garrett among others.

In actuality, if one looks at sales alone, a great number of people favored the Smith & Wesson Model 3 American and Schofield. The faster loading Smith & Wesson Model 3 was enormously popular, and that's including with the U.S. Army Cavalry who found it easier to load while on horseback because it ejected it's spent shells using only one hand. 

Fact is Smith & Wesson Model 3 American and Schofield pistols rivaled the popular Colt SAA revolver. And if you have ever tried loading and reloading a Colt Single Action Army vs a Smith & Wesson Model 3 American and Schofield, you know that it's hands down faster to load than the Colt SAA. In fact. it was because of it's ability to eject spent shells and reload faster that Wells Fargo became one of the largest purchasers and users of the Smith & Wesson Model 3. Besides the double barrel shotgun, it was their issue sidearm for their Detectives and Security personnel. 

As for Wyatt Earp using a Smith & Wesson Model 3 at the OK Corral, there is another point that we should look at when asking ourselves if he used a supposed Colt that was known as a Buntline Special with a 10 to 12 inch barrel or if he had used an Smith & Wesson Model 3 which was sold with a standard 6.5 inch barrel.

In the Court transcript, Wyatt Earp testified about his actions on the way to the lot near the OK Corral. In the Court transcript, Wyatt Earp says the following, "I took my pistol, which I had in my hand, under my coat, and put it in my overcoat pocket." 

Now folks, unless he had an overcoat with pockets that stretched down to his knees or lower, there is no way that he could have tried concealing a supposed Colt Buntline Special with a 10 to 12 inch barrel in an overcoat pocket. And yes, if you recall, he placed his pistol in his pocket to get it out of his hand and conceal it. Something that he could have done that very easily with a shorter Smith & Wesson Model 3.

UPDATE: July 13, 2017

It appears my summary of Wyatt Earp's life has upset a great number of people who cannot separate the Hollywood legend from the real man. Because of that fact, I'm removing that summary so that the gist of the story is no longer clouded by those who feel they have to defend Wyatt Earp to me.

The reason that I had put the summary in this article was to point out how the property of a notorious figure in history can garner more money at an auction if that property is proven to be authentic. I did not put that summary here to overshadow the point of this story which is to point out that the pistol that Wyatt Earp used at the shootout near the OK Corral was actually a Smith & Wesson Model 3 and not the mythical Colt Buntline Special that Hollywood and fiction writers would like us to believe he used.

The response to this article has taught me that there are a great number of people who love being lied to by Hollywood and the media. If you are a little curious about the other side of the Wyatt Earp legend, more on his character, please read Wyatt Earp -- From Unknown To Notorious Desperado.

As for books that I use as some of my sources, I take a look at which Earp books that I've found very good, very objection, in my critique of Earp books in my three part series, Wyatt Earp's Biography By Stuart Lake -- Part 1. You may find that information interesting.

Tom Correa


32 comments:

  1. I attended (and participated in) that 2014 auction in Scottsdale and have a nice file of pre- and post-sale news clippings, pictures, and catalogue notes. It was quite an event. Boyer's files got quite a bit of attention---of personal interest was a display which showed several prominent figures of "the day", including Holliday, Masterson, and my g-grandfather, but NOT Wyatt. Kinda interesting. The copious back-up notes on the W.E. Colt are an interesting memento. Bob Paul

    ReplyDelete
  2. There's a lot of talk in this article about Wyatt Earp being a con-man, a swindler and in trouble with the law on occasion. Where's the proof of this? I am not disputing anyone, but what book(s), local records or where does this opinion come from?

    It's hard to make a living and I have worked as a bartender, bouncer, cowboy, outfitter/packer, gold prospector, miner and earned my money on horseback chasing cows and sheep for many years. I have been in trouble with the law disturbing the peace, punched the Sheriff, etc. In addition, I have served my country, paid my taxes, raised a family and have been a contributing member of the community.

    That's why I have a hard time viewing Wyatt Earp as a confidence man, swindler or being notorious when we all make a living and get through life the best we can. Anyway, I would be interested in reading any "documented" info that proves Mr. Earp's dark side. Can you please point me in the right direction for info or books on this fascinating subject? Thanks... Charlie

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Both of the more recent Hollywood movies ("Wyatt Earp" and "Tombstone") have covered his horse-stealing, relationships with "soiled doves", work in gambling parlors, refereeing prize fights, etc., so you aren't exactly breaking new ground with this stuff. For someone who USUALLY "fact checks everything", you've got precious little on display here in the way of documented sources to back up your more odious assertions about Wyatt Earp. In fact, the only primary sources you mention here deal only with what type of pistol Wyatt used at the OK Corral, and bring nothing to bear on the man's general character.

      Actually, this whole blog post reads like the opinions of someone who is a descendant of either the Clanton or McLowry family, trying to smear a legend.

      Delete
    2. The research I've done indicated that Wyatt used a model 3. I agree with you.

      Delete
    3. Hello Charlie Swearingen, I've had to delete a lot of my responses because of the need for space. As for pointing you in the right direction for info or books on the Earps? I'm coming out with an article talking about Stuart Lake's Earp book and how it led me to others. Which ones were found to be bullshit and which ones are more credible. Thanks for visiting my sit. Respectfully, Tom

      Delete
    4. Hello Offonroad, Thanks. My research indicates the same thing. Again, much thanks. Thanks for visiting my sit. Respectfully, Tom

      Delete
    5. Hello Anonymous from October 31, 2016. I've had to delete a lot of my responses because of the need for space. But I will say this, please read the other articles that I have written on Wyatt Earp. In those articles, I call him a pimp, a horse thief, a con artist, a murderer, and so on. In those articles, I explain why those labels appropriately apply to him. You may find it interesting reading. Thanks for visiting my sit. Respectfully, Tom

      Delete
  3. I dont agree and although the legend is never all that they make it out to be , Wyatt had been a law man all of his life and was indeed well known because of it , in the day , that got around fast , which being a lawman was why he was able to be involved the the OK corral stuff in the first place. Im not sure where you got your information but its far from correct, There is documented proof to the contrare

    ReplyDelete
  4. Gotta agree with Tom, I have seen a photo copy of the writ for “horse theft,” actually I think there were 2 horses. Likewise the “pimp,” bartender and brothel owner/manager days of Wyatt’s life are all well documented. Additionally, at least two of the women Wyatt lived with or married were “soiled doves” as they were known in those days. As far as his days as a lawman they were sporadic throughout his life and never seemed to last long. I don’t know if the “three years” that Tom mentioned in his article is correct or not but I don’t think it’s far off. Most “police” jobs in those days were temporary at best with nothing like civil service protection. Except for the various states that had elected County Sheriff’s (with specific terms of office) virtually all law enforcement officers served “at will” to a fickled city or town council, Mayor and even the US Marshal (who hired and fired at will.) So Wyatt’s law-dog days were probably very short lived and sporadic and further effected by his nomadic ways. I remember reading Lakes biography of Wyatt as a kid and I’ve watched “Tombstone” several times but I don’t think there’s a whole lot of FACT in either one, sad to say! It’s a fact that everyone has peaks and valleys in their lives. I also don’t think those peaks should be discounted just because of the valleys. They just need to be balanced with the realities of the time and a man’s moment in history.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'd just like to comment on what I've read on this site. I remember reading quite a well researched, recent biography on Wyatt Earp, he did get into trouble in his early years with stealing a horse; however, it wasn't as cut and dried as you make out, he was never convicted of horse theft. Wyatt appears to have lost his way for a number of years, especially after the death of his young wife. I don't understand exactly what you're trying to make him out to be. Was the man a saint, certainly not, was he human, definitely yes. He wasn't a cold blooded murderer or a bank robber. He was like a lot of men on the frontier at that time, trying to make a living. Truth be told he didn't have a particularly distinguished law career before Tombestone, and he went there to make it rich. He ended up involving himself in a complex situation that spiralled out of control, one brother was murdered another was crippled for life. He responded the only way he thought he could. I don't necessarily agree with everything he did, or how he's been portrayed over the years; but he was a man of his times, can you or I imagine ourselves in his position and what we'd do, I think not.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've had to delete a lot of my responses because of the need for space. But please read the other articles that I have written on Wyatt Earp. In those articles, I call him a pimp, a horse thief, a con artist, a murderer, and so on. In those articles, I explain why those labels appropriately apply to him. I'm just looking at a historical figure and examining the facts. Thanks for visiting my sit.

      Delete
  6. Hollywood has tainted the history of the west. From what the American Indian to Wyatt Earp. Sadly a lot of what really went on in the old weast has been lost and retold through Hollywood and Buffalo Bill Cody Wild West show.

    ReplyDelete
  7. "This is the West, sir. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend." --The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. I'm grateful for Mr. Correa's extensive, painstaking research to uncover the legend of Wyatt Earp and to expose the truth about the man. A real man--a real cowboy lives by a code: always tell the truth, regardless. If man's word is not his bond, then he has nothing. And good reputation is more valuable than gold. Mr. Correa lives by that code. Perhaps, sir, you will write an in-depth book on the so-called myths, legends, and lies about the men and women of the old west that Hollywood has seen fit to perpetuate for decades. --J.D. Lone Bear McGowan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you. You cannot know how much I appreciate that all of my research is appreciated. And yes, I am working on a book. Thanks again J.D.

      Delete
  8. "This is the West, sir. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend." --The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. I'm grateful for Mr. Correa's extensive, painstaking research to uncover the legend of Wyatt Earp and to expose the truth about the man. A real man--a real cowboy lives by a code: always tell the truth, regardless. If man's word is not his bond, then he has nothing. And good reputation is more valuable than gold. Mr. Correa lives by that code. Perhaps, sir, you will write an in-depth book on the so-called myths, legends, and lies about the men and women of the old west that Hollywood has seen fit to perpetuate for decades. J.D. Lone Bear McGowan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. J.D., I cannot thank you enough for the kind words. And yes, I'm working on a book right now.

      Delete
  9. If somebody had killed one of my brothers, and crippled the other one, I don't know if I could do what he did to hunt them down and kill them, risking his own life. I take my hat off to him and the vengeance ride posse for that. Did he create peace in Tombstone and the county, well after the McClaurys, most of the Clantons, Curly Bill Brocious, Johnny Ringo. Frank Stillwell, the Indian Cruz, and others were gone, yes, there was finally peace from the cowboys in Tombstone. Hey Tom, what great work for mankind have you risked your life for and done in your lifetime?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Pimping and bookers were legal in most places in the West especially in the boomtowns. Wyatt. Wasn't breaking the law running whore houses. Look as most of the,other law men of the old west. Most were gamblers and killers. They used their badges to collect bounties on some very nasty evil people. I was in law enforcement for 17 years and I wish we could have just shot some bad guys, instead of waitting til they shot first. Times were very different back then. Very few laws or trained law men. I think Wyatt did what needed to be done at the time. Bat Masterson has very high regards for Wyatt. And I don't think Bat would have felt that way if Wyatt was as bad as you think he was. No body is perfect aspecailly in the Old West. Imho

    ReplyDelete
  11. Seriously, I can't believe some of the comments here that question,totally misunderstand, contradict or spin what looks like to me Mr.Correa's thoughtful,reasoned,researched statements. It feels like some people, perhaps 1/3 of Americans now? will believe any fantasy, any distortion, exaggeration or downright lie that appeals to them about anything, not just history but current events? Why, because "their side" believes it or it's more "exciting",or "romantic", or gets one "stirred up?" What a sad state of affairs for this great nation. Factual history and current events are so much more complex and interesting than imaginary scenarios anyway.
    But Years ago, the Franklin Mint company sold "exact reproductions" of a/the "Earp pistol", a full scale, rather well made, soft metal non-firing close copy of the No. 3 2ND Model S&W American. In fact though, I see here that the Joseph Rosa book states that Earp had the "New" Model No. 3, which is very, very different from the older Model 3. Much easier to handle, carry for one thing. Now that is interesting, and I feel fairly safe believing that, given the context of this blog. So thanks for that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your support. I truly appreciate it.

      Delete
  12. Your site is truly cool and this is an awesome rousing article. Much obliged to you to such an extent. Combat Handgun Training

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you. I really do appreciate you saying that.

      Delete
  13. Mr. Correa,

    You omitted a particular episode of Wyatt Earp's life. The County of San Bernardino, California, made Wyatt Earp an Honorary Deputy Sheriff. A number of years ago, I listened to a historian at Cal State San Bernardino give a presentation on him.

    An elderly Wyatt Earp (in his 60s) was prospecting in the California desert when he was approached by a young, inexperienced peace officer. The young peace officer asked Earp for help. An armed robber was holding up the local general store. Earp told the young peace officer to cover the back of the store. Earp (unarmed) then walked to the front entrance of the general store, announced "I'm Wyatt Earp" to the stunned robber, approached him, disarmed him, grabbed him by the collar, and threw him out the front door. This story is consistent with other accounts of how Earp exhibited fearlessness and cool courage when the need arose.

    You also left out the story of how Wyatt Earp, while serving as a Kansas peace officer, found a drunken man lying unconscious in the street; took him to the jail; and did not steal the $300 that was in his pocket. Because of this, the local newspaper praised Earp as an honest peace officer. This was cited in a recent Earp biography.

    You also left out the story of Wyatt Earp (age 73) attending a group luncheon in Los Angeles in 1923. Apparently two young men of the Jazz Age were sitting across from him at the table, and taking disrespectfully about women. Wyatt Earp responded by standing up at the table, glowering at them, and saying "You don't talk about a woman like that." I believe that in an earlier age, they called this chivalry.

    The frontier was not a black-and-white place. There was no guaranteed employment or government safety net. People were living meal-to-meal. The money was either in the saloons or in prospecting (which very few people were successful at). Earp went where the money was - in the saloons which were town social centers for men at the time (the YMCA wasn't available).

    Women were also in short supply on the frontier, particularly in a violent mining town like Tombstone, in the middle of Apache country, within 30 miles of the lawless Mexican border. That's why a local rancher would occasionally marry a "soiled dove." These ladies appreciated a good man, having seen the worst of men. Common-law marriages were also legal and recognized at the time. So, it's not surprising that Earp had two or three soiled doves as common-law wives.

    As an earlier respondent indicated, Wyatt Earp lost his way for a time after his first wife died. In later life, he lived in poverty. Unlike many of our contemporaries, Wyatt didn't try to lift himself out of poverty by selling drugs or committing violent crimes against innocent people.
    There was also a frontier tradition of cleaning out a "greenhorn" in his first card game in order to teach him a lesson on being careful with whom he played cards.

    Mr. Correa, you seem to dwell excessively on Wyatt Earp's shortcomings as seen from a modern perspective. People should be judged by the standards of their own time -- not by those of another age. Earp was not a saint, but then I've never met a "saint" in my 60 years. Just as Perry Mason inspired many people to study the law, Wyatt Earp inspired many people to become peace officers.

    In closing, Mr. Correa, I believe that this biblical verse applies to you. "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have never said that I'm without sin. But really, what does that have to do with examining people and/or events in our history? Since none of us are without sin, does that mean that none of us should examine the lives of people and/or events in our history? That's ludicrous. I examine everyone with the same gauge, the same measuring stick, in the same way. Yes, simply by looking at facts.

      Thank you for visiting my site.
      Tom

      Delete
  14. Mr. Correa, Your article which was o.k., should have stuck to its title rather impugning a man's character without posting all the facts. I would suggest you read and look at a lot more facts than you have regarding Wyatt Earp. I suggest reading Wyatt Earp Speaks! written by Wyatt Earp and others, edited by John Stephens published by Fall River Press 2009. It is a well documented book, in which Mr.Earp dispels the legend from Hollywood and other writers.

    ReplyDelete
  15. He was a Law Man in Kansas, as I am too. I'm sure he wasn't perfect, and made mistakes in his life as I have mine. I am proud to wear a badge and gun, and up hold the laws of Kansas as once the great legend, Wyatt Earp.
    T. Dietz

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Officer Dietz, Thank you for your service. I have always been pro-Law Enforcement. It is just my opinion, but Earp was not a lawmen very long at all because he wasn't a very good lawmen. Just my opinion. I'm sure you're a thousand times better the lawmen than Earp ever was. And yes, you have my respect for that. Best Regards, Please Stay Safe, Tom Correa

      Delete
  16. Tom, while I agree that Hollyweird more than likely inflated history for profits, I find that you are a petty person that wouldn't have lasted a day in the times of Wyatt Earp. Not a single person knows the exact truth of his life, yet you seem so sure of yourself. You sound like a bitter, and petty man

    ReplyDelete
  17. OK...The question here is not whether Wyatt was a good or bad man, a pimp, an outlaw, or a lawman in good standing. The question is, did Wyatt use a Colt or a Smith at the O.K. Corral? With all due respect, according to Tom, Boorman, Rosa and Lake all say he used a Smith #3. What or who is their source for this? Is their source Lake? From the standpoint of a historian, what I'm interested in is where did Lake get his information? Lake wrote long before Boorman and Rosa, right? Are Boorman and Rosa just quoting Lake, or do they cite another source? My recollection is that most of the "facts" provided to Lake came from Wyatt's wife Josephine (Sadie), and I seriously doubt she'd have known a Colt from a Remington from a Smith #3--from a Winchester Model 73. Lake conducted eight short interviews with Wyatt, and got a "bare sketch" of Wyatt's life. I find it hard to believe that during those interviews, Wyatt, recounting his life, noted he'd used a S&W #3 at the O.K. fight. At the time of the interviews, Wyatt was in his 80s. I believe Lake went to Wyatt's wife Josephine after Wyatt's death to fill in the blanks. Any facts Lake didn't get from Josephine, he made up himself. This question isn't something I've personally researched, although I read Lake many years ago, and a couple of other better biographies of Wyatt. I believe a large part of what Lake wrote was B.S., i.e., fiction. Personally, if all this hinges on Lake's testimony, I'd be very suspicious. I don't personally have a dog in this fight, but from a historical standpoint, it's just about impossible to say what make of pistol Wyatt used in the fight. I'd want to see a couple of very solid sources, and Lake isn't what I'd call "solid." Even Billy the Kid was photographed with his weapons. I don't believe Wyatt was, and certainly not at the time. The fact is, like so much of the history of the American west, there is probably no reliable way to know.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you on many points you make. But it was Wyatt Earp's book written by Stuart Lake where the whole Buntline Special myth comes from. As for the Smith & Wesson Model 3 American that Earp owned, we know for fact that Wyatt Earp was given a .44 Smith & Wesson Model 3 by Tombstone Mayor John Clum just days before the OK Corral shootout. Clum was mayor of Tombstone and owner/editor of the Tombstone Epitath. The idea that Earp carried a Buntline Special given to him by Ned Buntline is all fictional. That was something that Wyatt Earp told Stuart Lake for Earp's biography. The Buntline never existed. And if it did, I'd love to know how Ned Buntline could give such a long barreled Colt commemorative pistol to lawmen who were not yet lawmen at the time the Buntline was alive? The reason that people accept the idea that Wyatt Earp carried the Buntline Special at the OK Corral was because of Earp's book which has been disproved as work of fiction. And while it is said that Earp only met with Lake a few times, those meeting could have lasted hours instead of just a few minutes as some speculate. We know that Wyatt Earp loved to spin yarns on the Hollywood sets. We know he spent days spinning yarns. We also know that many of his claims such as arresting gunfighter Ben Thompson are not true. So with that, I believe we can only go with what Clum and eyewitnesses said as for what pistol he used at the OK Corral.

      Delete
  18. I very much enjoy your articles on Wyatt Earp and I enjoy even more the responses people write. I've been in law enforcement over thirty years and I'm sure no one will write books or make movies about my life. If as you say Wyatt was in law enforcement three years what an impression he made. One person wrote it wasn't against the law to run whore houses and he is correct. I live in a small town in Colorado and can remember in the 60's the county sheriff having one outside of town. Anyway great stories and great comments.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Before anything else, I want to thank you for your service. Being in law enforcement has always been a thankless job, but it seems these days that's even more the case. As for the idea that running a whorehouse was not against the law? Yes, just as today, in some jurisdictions it's not against the law. For example, even today, Nevada state law makes brothels legal. Right across the state line in California, brothels are illegal. The same took place in the 1800s. That's why Earp was arrested on 3 different occasions in Illinois for being a pimp. As for Wyatt Earp being a lawman for a little over three years? I think it was closer to 4 years if we count the time he was a constable. As for his making an impression as a lawman? He really didn't leave a very good impression at the time. He was considered "notorious" and "infamous". He stayed out of Arizona because he was wanted for the murder of Frank Stilwell. His personal history was re-written because of Hollywood. Just as the Dime Novels and Harper's made Wild Bill famous, Hollywood made Wyatt Earp famous. Many of who we see as Old West "legends" really did not work as lawmen for very long. Dime Novelist and Hollywood has made them who they are today. If memory serves me right, I think Bat Masterson had been a lawmen all toll for about 5 years in 3 different places, and I think Wild Bill was a lawman for about 2 years in 2 different places. There were real career lawmen in the Old West who we sadly don't hear about. Some of them were Harry C. Wheeler, Frank Dalton, Harry Nicholson Morse, John Hicks Adams, and Tom Threepersons. These were real tough as nails lawmen who spent their entire lives standing tall for the law, hunting criminals, bringing in bad guys, and doing what was needed. Sadly, few have heard their names. Many were really famous in their day. I really believe that they didn't get the press simply because Hollywood didn't make them famous like it did with Wyatt Earp and a few others. So sadly, their names are more or less forgotten today. Thanks for visiting my blog. I truly appreciate it.

      Delete

Thank you for your comment.